Is formal logic useful in argumentation? The case for political usefulness

  • Víctor Manuel Peralta Del Riego Universidad del Caribe
DOI: https://doi.org/10.32870/qr.v2i3.48
Keywords: formal analysis, argumentation, politics, law, logic.

Abstract

Reception: November 28, 2016     Accepted: December 20, 2016 In this paper I will attempt to answer the question of whether formal logic is of any use to the human and precise activity of argumentation. In order to tackle the original question I undertake a more specific one: is formal logic useful for our political and juridical argumentations? My short answer is yes. I provide an example of a general analysis of justification of acts of authority that is both logically valid and novel as to how this task is correctly accomplished. An analysis of this sort is not correct politically, but rather logically and common-sensically. I propose a way to formally analyze political discourse, and then show how it can be used to improve our understanding of it, via an improvement of clarity and precision.

Author Biography

Víctor Manuel Peralta Del Riego, Universidad del Caribe
Estudié la licenciatura en Filosofía, de 2000 a 2004, en la Universidad Autónoma de Zacatecas. Pasante de la licenciatura en Derecho, de 2000 a 2005. Pasante de la maestría en Filosofía, especialidad en Lógica, Filosofía de la mente y del lenguaje, de la UNAM, de la generación 2005 a 2007. Actualmente soy profesor de 'desarrollo de habilidades del pensamiento' de la Universidad del Caribe, Cancún.

References

ESTAGIRA, Aristóteles de (1989). Politeia (la Política). (Prólogo, traducción y notas por M. Briceño Jáuregui; estudio preliminar e introducciones por I. Restrepo Abondano). Bogotá, Colombia: Imprenta

Patriótica del Instituto Caro y Cuervo.

ATIENZA, M. (2005). Las Razones del Derecho. México: IIJ-UNAM.

GARSON, J. (Primavera de 2016). “Modal Logic”. En E. N. Zalta (ed.) The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, recuperado de: http://plato.stanford.edu/archives/spr2016/entries/logic-modal/

HERNÁNDEZ Ortiz, H., R. Parra, y V. M. Peralta del Riego (2015). Falacias y racionalidad. Cancún: Universidad del Caribe.

HUGHES, G. y M. Cresswell (1984). A Companion to Modal Logic. London: Methuen.

PERALTA DEL RIEGO, V. M. (2016). La apelación a la mayoría y los límites a la democracia. Ponencia presentada en el 5to Congreso Internacional de Ciencias Sociales en el Sureste Mexicano.

SIDER, T. (2009). Logic for Philosophy. [Borrador, mayo de 2009]. Recuperado en 2011 de: http://tedsider.org/

SMULLYAN, R. (1961). Theory of Formal Systems. Princeton, New Jersey: Princeton University Press.

Published
2017-01-01
Issue
No 3 (2017): ARGUMENTATION IN PHILOSOPHY AND THE USES OF FORMAL LOGIC IN ARGUMENTATION AND POLITICAL REFLECTION
Section
Articles

Once the text is accepted for publication in Quadripartita Ratio, the authors must sign two legal documents: the License of Use and the Declaration of Authorship.

With the License of Use, the authors agree to the publication and diffusion of their work (integration in databases, diffusion in our social media, possible reeditions, etc.). However, it authorizes the download, reproduction and distribution of all published content, as long as the content is not modified and the source is indicated (name of the journal, volume, number, pages and electronic address of the document).

With the Declaration of Authorship, the authors manifest that the work is theirs, original and unpublished.